Reynoldstown Homes for Sale
One of Atlanta's oldest neighborhoods, founded in the 1860s after the Civil War. Today the BeltLine Eastside Trail runs along its western edge, Krog Street Market sits on the corner, and the historic shotgun stock now shares blocks with new mid-rise and townhome construction.
Live data from FMLS, refreshed every 15 minutes. Based on active listings whose FMLS subdivision matches Reynoldstown.
Why Reynoldstown Appeals
Reynoldstown is one of the oldest neighborhoods in Atlanta. It was founded in the 1860s and 1870s by freedmen working on the Georgia Railroad and named for one of those early settlers, Madison Reynolds. For most of the 20th century it stayed quiet, residential, and largely under the radar. Over the last 15 years that has changed dramatically. The BeltLine Eastside Trail extension cut along the western edge of the neighborhood, Krog Street Market opened on the northwest corner in 2014, and the housing stock has shifted from mostly historic shotgun homes and craftsman bungalows to a mix that now includes substantial new mid-rise apartment buildings, townhome rows, and infill single-family.
Geographically, Reynoldstown sits south of Inman Park, east of Cabbagetown, west of Edgewood, and north of Grant Park. The MARTA Inman Park-Reynoldstown station on the Blue and Green lines is on the eastern edge. The Eastside Trail and Krog Street Market are within a short walk for most blocks. Walk Score is very high, especially on the BeltLine-adjacent streets, and Bike Score is high across the whole neighborhood. The school catchment is Burgess-Peterson Academy, King Middle, and Maynard Jackson High, all APS.
Here's the trade-off. Reynoldstown packages BeltLine adjacency, Krog Street Market on the corner, MARTA rail on the edge, and intown walkability into one address, and there aren't many other neighborhoods in Atlanta that put all four together. The catch is that you're buying into a place that's actively still changing. Renovated historic single-family generally trades $600k to $1.1M, new builds $700k to $1.5M, and townhomes $400k to $700k, but the inventory varies wildly by housing type and the streetscape can shift block by block. If you want one consistent visual character street to street, Inman Park or Cabbagetown will feel more settled. If you want the BeltLine plus Krog plus rail plus walkability in one package, Reynoldstown is the answer.
Active Inventory
See all 12 listings
Active listings in Reynoldstown.
Showing 12 of 12 active listings.
MLS# 7749037
MLS# 7766421
MLS# 7766040
MLS# 7767392
MLS# 7754829
MLS# 7737738
MLS# 7744790
MLS# 7723420
MLS# 7728719
MLS# 7758421
MLS# 7704177
MLS# 7743724
See 9 more homes for sale in Reynoldstown
What Makes Reynoldstown Distinctive
One of Atlanta's oldest neighborhoods
Reynoldstown was founded in the 1860s and 1870s by freedmen who worked on the Georgia Railroad, and it took its name from Madison Reynolds, one of those early settlers. The bones of the original street grid and a meaningful share of the historic shotgun and bungalow stock are still in place, even after 15 years of heavy redevelopment along the BeltLine corridor.
BeltLine Eastside Trail on the western edge
The Atlanta BeltLine Eastside Trail runs along the western edge of Reynoldstown, which means residents step off their block onto a paved path that connects north to Inman Park and Ponce City Market and south toward Memorial Drive and Glenwood Park. The Trail is the single biggest reason the neighborhood's value curve has shifted over the last decade.
Krog Street Market on the corner
Krog Street Market, the food hall and retail destination inside the renovated Atlanta Stove Works building, sits on the northwestern edge of Reynoldstown. Walkable from most of the neighborhood. Food hall, butcher, retail, and a regular calendar of events. One of the original anchors of intown Atlanta's food-hall era.
MARTA Inman Park-Reynoldstown station
The Blue and Green line MARTA station sits on the eastern edge of the neighborhood, giving residents direct rail access to Five Points, downtown, Decatur, and (via transfer) Hartsfield-Jackson Airport without driving. Combined with the BeltLine, this is one of the few intown neighborhoods where a car-light life genuinely works.
Mixed historic and new-build stock
The housing mix now includes smaller historic shotgun homes, 1910s to 1930s craftsman bungalows, post-war cottages, and a substantial layer of newer mid-rise apartments, townhome rows, and infill single-family along the BeltLine and Memorial Drive. Block-by-block character varies more here than in Cabbagetown or Inman Park.
BeltLine plus Krog plus rail plus walkability in one package
Few intown neighborhoods put all four together. Inman Park has the BeltLine and walkability but at a higher price tier and with a lighter MARTA connection. Cabbagetown has Krog and walkability but no rail station on the edge. Reynoldstown is the address that bundles the four amenities, which is a meaningful share of why demand has stayed firm here through every recent market cycle.
Reynoldstown real estate market.
Living in Reynoldstown
Dining & Entertainment
Krog Street Market
Food hall and retail destination on the northwestern corner of Reynoldstown. Multiple restaurants, a butcher, and a steady calendar of events inside the renovated Atlanta Stove Works building. Walkable from most of the neighborhood.
krogstreetmarket.com/Beetlecat
Seafood restaurant from Ford Fry on Krog Street. A regular special-occasion option for the neighborhood, and one of the longest-running anchors of the Krog Street food scene.
Argosy
Beer hall and pizza spot on Flat Shoals Avenue in East Atlanta Village, a short drive south. A frequent weeknight option for Reynoldstown residents.
Memorial Drive corridor
The Memorial Drive commercial corridor along the southern edge of the neighborhood has added a steady stream of independent restaurants, breweries, and coffee shops over the last decade. Walkable from the southern blocks.
Inman Park dining
The Highland and Euclid village stretch in Inman Park is a 5 to 10 minute walk north. Neighborhood-favorite restaurants and bars at village scale.
Shopping & Services
Krog Street Market retail
Independent retail and specialty food alongside the food hall. Walkable from most of Reynoldstown.
krogstreetmarket.com/Memorial Drive corridor
The Memorial Drive corridor has steadily added independent retail, breweries, and small grocers over the last decade. Walkable from the southern blocks.
Edgewood Retail District
Mid-scale retail anchor with grocery, big-box stores, and everyday services on Caroline Street, a short drive east.
Little Five Points
Independent record stores, vintage shops, bookstores, and tattoo studios. About a 10-minute walk or short drive northeast.
Ponce City Market
Whole Foods, the food hall, retail, and the rooftop in the renovated Sears building. Roughly a 10-minute drive or 20-minute BeltLine walk north.
poncecitymarket.com/Recreation & Parks
BeltLine Eastside Trail
Paved walking and biking trail along the western edge of Reynoldstown, connecting north to Inman Park and Ponce City Market and south toward Memorial Drive. The single biggest recreational asset in the neighborhood.
beltline.org/Lang Carson Park
Public park inside Reynoldstown with playing fields, a recreation center, and a community pool. The neighborhood's primary green space and weekly anchor for many residents.
Stanton Park
Smaller neighborhood park on the eastern side of Reynoldstown. Walking paths and quiet green space inside the residential blocks.
Grant Park
131-acre park immediately south of the neighborhood, including Zoo Atlanta. Walking paths, mature canopy, and one of Atlanta's oldest public parks.
grantpark.org/Freedom Park trails
210-acre linear park to the north with paved trails through tree canopy. Connects east toward Candler Park and west toward the Carter Center, accessible via the BeltLine and the residential streets.
Annual Events
Reynoldstown Wheelbarrow Festival
The neighborhood's signature annual event, run since the 1990s. Spring weekend with a wheelbarrow parade, live music, and a neighborhood-wide block party. One of the longer-running small festivals on Atlanta's east side.
Atlanta BeltLine Lantern Parade
Annual September parade along the BeltLine Eastside Trail, walkable from any block in Reynoldstown.
beltline.org/Krog Street Market events
Year-round programming including seasonal markets, pop-ups, and live music inside and outside the food hall.
krogstreetmarket.com/Inman Park Festival
The Inman Park festival is a short walk north and draws a meaningful share of the Reynoldstown crowd every spring. Parade, juried artists market, Tour of Homes, and live music.
inmanparkfestival.org/Architecture in Reynoldstown
~25% of stock
Shotgun and Folk Cottage
Narrow, single-story homes one room wide and several rooms deep, often with a front porch and a gabled roofline. Built mostly between the 1880s and the 1910s as the neighborhood grew up around the Georgia Railroad. The historic baseline of Reynoldstown.
~25% of stock
Craftsman Bungalow
Front-gabled or side-gabled rooflines, deep front porches with tapered columns, exposed rafter tails, original heart pine floors, wood clapboard or shingle siding. Built mostly between 1910 and 1930 as the neighborhood expanded.
~15% of stock
Post-War Cottage and Ranch
Smaller mid-century homes built between the 1940s and the 1960s. Brick or clapboard exteriors, less ornamental detail than the bungalow stock, often with side or rear additions added later. Concentrated on the eastern and southern blocks.
~15% of stock
Modern Infill Single-Family
Newer single-family construction concentrated along the BeltLine and on tear-down lots throughout the neighborhood. Two- and three-story plans, contemporary or transitional facades, attached garages, larger square footage than the historic stock.
~20% of stock
Townhome and Mid-Rise Condo
Townhome rows and mid-rise apartment and condo buildings concentrated along Memorial Drive and the BeltLine. Three- and four-story plans, rooftop decks, attached garages, lock-and-leave layouts.
Reynoldstown Schools
Burgess-Peterson Academy
Atlanta Public Schools, grades pre-K through 5. The assigned elementary for most of Reynoldstown. Continued investment over recent years. Confirm current zone assignment with APS before relying on it for an offer.
Martin Luther King Jr. Middle School
APS middle school, grades 6 through 8. Serves Reynoldstown and several adjacent intown neighborhoods. Confirm zone assignment with APS during due diligence.
Maynard H. Jackson High School
APS high school, grades 9 through 12. Serves Reynoldstown, East Atlanta, Kirkwood, and several adjacent neighborhoods. Confirm zone assignment with APS.
Private school options near Reynoldstown include The Paideia School (Druid Hills), Atlanta International School, and a short drive farther for The Westminster Schools, The Lovett School, and Pace Academy. Confirm tuition and admissions calendars directly with each school.
Getting Around Reynoldstown
Reynoldstown is one of the few intown neighborhoods where a car-light life genuinely works. The MARTA Blue and Green line station on the eastern edge connects directly to Five Points, downtown, Decatur, and (via transfer at Five Points) Hartsfield-Jackson Airport. The BeltLine Eastside Trail along the western edge handles much of the daily north-south recreational and errand traffic. Daily errands at Krog Street Market and along Memorial Drive are walkable for most of the neighborhood. For trips outside the BeltLine corridor or the rail lines, residents drive, but a meaningful share of weekly life happens on foot, bike, or rail.
Typical commute times
Downtown Atlanta (Five Points)
8–14 min by car, ~7 min via MARTA
Midtown / Tech Square
12–18 min off-peak via Ponce or North Avenue
Decatur Square
10–15 min by car, ~12 min via MARTA
Buckhead
18–25 min off-peak via I-75/85
Hartsfield-Jackson Airport
20–30 min by car, ~30 min via MARTA
Emory University / CDC
12–18 min off-peak via Moreland or Ponce
I-20 is accessible via Moreland Avenue or Boulevard, both within about 5 minutes. I-75 and I-85 (the Connector) are reachable via Freedom Parkway, North Avenue, or I-20 west, generally 8 to 12 minutes off-peak.
Frequently asked questions.
What's the median home price in Reynoldstown?
Renovated historic single-family in Reynoldstown generally trades in the $600k to $1.1M range over the last 12 months. Newer infill single-family and substantial new builds run $700k to $1.5M. Townhomes typically run $400k to $700k. Active single-family inventory inside the neighborhood is usually 15 to 30 listings at any given time, with another 10 to 25 townhome and condo listings concentrated along Memorial Drive and the BeltLine.
How is the Reynoldstown market right now?
Closed sales over the last year have run roughly 25 to 50 days on market, with well-prepared single-family on BeltLine-adjacent blocks moving in 14 to 25 days and townhomes varying more by price point. Demand stays steady because of the BeltLine plus Krog plus rail combination, which keeps Reynoldstown firmly in the rotation for buyers who shopped Inman Park or Cabbagetown first and want similar walkability at a softer price point.
Is Reynoldstown walkable?
Yes, especially the blocks adjacent to the BeltLine, Krog Street Market, and Memorial Drive. Walk Score is in the high 70s to high 80s depending on the block. Krog Street Market, the BeltLine Eastside Trail, and the Memorial Drive retail stretch are all within a 5 to 10 minute walk from most homes. The MARTA Inman Park-Reynoldstown station on the eastern edge handles longer trips, and the bike infrastructure on the BeltLine is strong.
What schools are assigned to Reynoldstown?
Burgess-Peterson Academy for elementary, Martin Luther King Jr. Middle School, and Maynard H. Jackson High School in Atlanta Public Schools. Confirm current zone assignment with APS before relying on it for an offer, since boundaries can shift.
What architectural styles are common in Reynoldstown?
The historic stock leans on shotgun and folk cottages from the 1880s to 1910s (about 25%) and craftsman bungalows from 1910 to 1930 (about 25%). Post-war cottages and ranches make up another 15%. The newer layer is modern infill single-family along the BeltLine (about 15%) and townhome rows and mid-rise condos along Memorial Drive and the BeltLine (about 20%). Block-by-block character varies more here than in Cabbagetown or Inman Park because the neighborhood has changed faster over the last 15 years.
How does Reynoldstown compare to Inman Park or Cabbagetown?
Inman Park sits north and gives you deeper historic stock (Painted Ladies, Queen Annes) and a higher overall price tier, generally $1.2M to $2M for renovated single-family. Cabbagetown sits west and gives you a more uniform historic streetscape (mill houses, very small lots) and a slightly lower price band. Reynoldstown sits in the middle on price, packages BeltLine plus Krog plus MARTA rail plus walkability into one address, and offers the widest mix of housing types from townhomes at $450k up through new builds at $1.5M. Best fit depends on whether you prioritize architectural consistency, the specific price tier, or the four-amenity package.
Why work with VCG to buy or sell in Reynoldstown?
We specialize in intown Atlanta neighborhoods, including the ones where the streetscape is still actively shifting. Reynoldstown is one of those. We can walk you through the block-by-block math, talk through the trade-off between historic stock and newer construction on a specific street, and tell you which homes are quietly about to come up before they reach the MLS. For sellers, we'll walk through pricing scenarios for your specific block and the prep work that pays off here, where comps can vary significantly inside a few hundred feet.
Thinking about
Reynoldstown?
Thinking about Reynoldstown?
Listing data provided by FMLS and/or Georgia MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All measurements and conditions should be independently verified. Disclaimer: fmls.com/dmca